Whittaker biome diagram from Chapin, Matson, Mooney Ecosystem Ecology text.
There are general questions about the overarching role of climate in determining biomes vs. other state and interactive factors, as well as what the boundaries should be and how much to subdivide biomes.
With recent advances in our understanding of the distribution of climate across the globe, we can now see that some of the patterns were not detailed initially correctly. Andrew Elmore and I redrew the Whittaker biome diagram to also include the actual distribution of land area for each combination of temperature and precipitation.
A few major things change.
1) Tropical forests exist in areas much wetter than originally detailed. Much forest exists between 4.5 and 7 m of rain.
2) Most of the world's temperate wet forests are at about 4°C. Whittaker would have lopped off much of them.
3) There are scattered high precipitation areas between what was considered temperate and tropical wet forests. This happens to largely be Hawaii. These have never been classified into temperate vs. tropical biomes.
You also changed the division between deserts and grasslands (i.e. at 30 ºC deserts were below 500 mm for Whittaker but your line cuts 30 ºC at about 600 or 700 mm) ¿Why?
ReplyDeleteI have extracted values from your whittaker plot and have modelled the biomas (for my biogeography classes) using worldclim maps. Deserts apeared a bit larger than in other biome maps. Ana Cingolani
I'm not sure we meant to shift that boundary. It was never meant to be super-quantitative, so feel free to adjust it back. I remember Terry adjusting the demarcation for tundra and boreal, that's about it. --Joe
DeleteThank you for your answer!
ReplyDeleteThe change in the classification of temperate rain forests is very interesting. Would it be possible to obtain the data you used to produce that figure? Thanks
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeletesaludos cordiales, podría indicar cuales son sus fuentes?
DeleteDid you ever publish this revised biome classifier?
ReplyDeleteI was searching for a published version of this diagram and found a nearly identical one in Swann et al 2016 "Plant responses to increasing CO2 reduce estimates of climate impacts on drought severity" PNAS. Oddly they only attribute it to Whittaker.
ReplyDeleteRespect and that i have a tremendous offer: How Much House Renovation Cost old home renovation
ReplyDelete